respect-validation/docs/comparing-empty-values.md

Comparing empty values

The Undef, Blank, and Falsy validators all validate "empty-like" values, but they differ in strictness and use cases. This guide helps you understand when to use each one.

Quick Comparison

Input	Undef	Falsy	Blank
null	✅	✅	✅
''	✅	✅	✅
' '	❌	❌	✅
0	❌	✅	✅
0.0	❌	✅	✅
'0'	❌	✅	✅
'0.0'	❌	❌	✅
false	❌	✅	✅
[]	❌	✅	✅
['']	❌	❌	✅
[0]	❌	❌	✅
[' ']	❌	❌	✅
new stdClass()	❌	❌	✅

Legend: ✅ = valid (passes the validation), ❌ = invalid (does not pass the validation)

Understanding Each Validator

Undef (Most Restrictive)

The Undef validator is the most restrictive. It only considers two values as "undefined":

• null
• '' (empty string)

This validator is ideal when you want to check if a value was explicitly not provided, such as an optional form field that was left empty or a missing API parameter.

v::undef()->isValid(null); // true
v::undef()->isValid('');   // true
v::undef()->isValid(0);    // false - 0 is a defined value
v::undef()->isValid(' ');  // false - whitespace is defined

Use when: You need to distinguish between "no value provided" and "any value provided" (including zeros, whitespace, and empty arrays).

Falsy (Moderate)

The Falsy validator uses PHP's native empty() function behavior. It considers values that PHP treats as "empty" in boolean contexts:

• null
• '' (empty string)
• 0, 0.0 (zero numbers)
• '0' (string zero)
• false
• [] (empty array)

v::falsy()->isValid(null);  // true
v::falsy()->isValid('');    // true
v::falsy()->isValid(0);     // true
v::falsy()->isValid('0');   // true
v::falsy()->isValid(false); // true
v::falsy()->isValid([]);    // true
v::falsy()->isValid(' ');   // false - whitespace is not empty()

Use when: You want to match PHP's native "truthiness" behavior, such as validating values that would fail an if ($value) check.

Blank (Most Permissive)

The Blank validator is the most permissive. It considers a value blank if it contains no meaningful content:

• Everything that Falsy considers falsy
• Whitespace-only strings ( , \t, \n)
• Numeric strings representing zero ('0.0', '0.00')
• Arrays containing only blank values (recursively)
• Empty stdClass objects

v::blank()->isValid(null);           // true
v::blank()->isValid('');             // true
v::blank()->isValid('   ');          // true - whitespace only
v::blank()->isValid('0.0');          // true - numeric zero string
v::blank()->isValid(['']);           // true - array with blank value
v::blank()->isValid([[''], [0]]);    // true - nested blanks
v::blank()->isValid(new stdClass()); // true - empty object

Use when: You want to check if a value has any meaningful content at all, ignoring whitespace, zeros, and empty nested structures.

Common Scenarios

Form Validation

// Accept field only if user typed something meaningful
v::not(v::blank())->isValid($userInput);

// Check if optional field was provided at all
v::not(v::undef())->isValid($optionalField);

API Validation

// Parameter must be defined (null and empty string are not acceptable)
v::not(v::undef())->isValid($requiredParam);

// Parameter can be zero but not empty
v::not(v::undef())->isValid(0); // passes - 0 is defined

Conditional Logic

// Match PHP's if() behavior
v::falsy()->isValid($value); // same as: !$value

// Check for truly empty values beyond PHP's empty()
v::blank()->isValid($value);

Decision Guide

Choose the validator based on what you consider "empty":

1. Use Undef when only null and '' should be considered empty. Zero, false, and empty arrays are valid values.

2. Use Falsy when you want to match PHP's empty() behavior. Good for boolean-like checks.

3. Use Blank when whitespace-only strings, nested empty arrays, and empty objects should also be considered empty.

See Also

• Undef
• Blank
• Falsy
• NullType